I’m venturing out of LA for the next few days. I’m already inspired by my new surroundings. Upstate NY in the springtime is amazing. Pics to come shortly.
But I thought a new feature of comparing and contrasting two shows that on the surface might be similar, but in reality are very different would be a nice way to get all of our critical minds working. I’m finding lately that being SPECIFIC is where your VOICE comes through, and also where you can highlight another show’s voice well in spec scripts. Jokes or storylines in scripts are required, but how is your drama or comedy specific to your show, whether it’s a pilot or a spec of an exisiting show.
Let’s take Facebook for example. How will THE GOOD WIFE get Alicia Florick on FB differently than Liz Lemon’s attempt at Facebook on 30 ROCK? (Still a fav 30 Rock episode, btw. “Lemon, I just got finger banged.” Genius!) There’s a few obvious routes to go for jokes and drama here, but how these shows make it their own is what sets them apart from the rest. CSI, which gets criticized by some for being generic procedural is still CSI. A CSI case won’t mistakenly appear on FRINGE. It couldn’t.
So, when you’re in spec land, your story of COURGARTOWN has to be specific for that show. Not just something you thought would be funny so you guess you can fit it into the COUGARTOWN mold. See the difference?
WHY THESE SHOWS: Both MODERN FAMLIY and PARENTHOOD are brilliant shows. Both are written by some of the best talent working in TV today. Both are coming back for another season. And both have a new take on the traditional family. From standing in line for an iPad to finding your daughter with pot, these storylines could work for either show, but notice that each one has a specific TAKE on those storylines.
THE CASE FOR PARENTHOOD: First thing about Parenthood you need to know. Jason Katims. The genius team behind FRIDAY NIGHT LIGHTS brings their dramatic touch to the Braverman family. This project has been in development for aaaaawhile. The team at IMAGINE was well served to let the Katims clan take a stab at this.
While we all miss Steve Martin in the movie and no one can really top that…BUT the show version does a great job of juggling a large cast, bringing in relevant and current issues of being a parent, and still finding that sweet spot between awkward comedy and heart-warming family bonding.
An hour with the Bravermans feels like a night with a friend’s family. I say a friend’s family because everyone’s own family almost has too much drama, but spending an evening with my best friend’s family is always much more pleasurable. Yes, you can see some of the chinks on their armor, but overall, they’re a nice place to be.
THE CASE FOR MODERN FAMILY: Also juggling a large cast, MODERN FAMILY does a great job showing us a current take on family. Yes, they live near each other but they all have their own dramas. An annual stargazing trip, to trying to keep your marriage sexy, to ditching your mom at the mall, these storylines bring their own comedy to the average family routine. The Interview element here also keeps the viewers grounded in each character’s internal dialogue and doesn’t step on the comedy that comes with being a parent.
While the drama here might be more heightened for comedic effect, ala, Lilly the adopted Asian baby calling her Asian doctor Mamma, the show always brings it back to a warm reminder that family is family, good and bad. (Notice I didn’t say “good OR bad” because the show gets many comedic moments from the bad too. Like Cam and Mitchell bumping Lilly’s head against the ceiling. Hell, I let a friend of mine’s kid roll down two stairs, luckily they were carpeted, but I FEEL that fear and horror that Cam and Mitchell went through. And my friend and I actually had a good laugh at her daughter’s expense over that moment too. And besides that little reveal I am a favorite Aunt to many a kid. I don’t drop ‘em all.)
SO WHO WINS?: Katims purists might hate me here, but I vote MODERN FAMILY. I find that MODERN FAMILY has just as much heart as the hour-long drama in PARENTHOOD, but MODERN FAMILY manages to make you laugh too. And there’s something about family and being a parent that is so brutal sometimes, that wrapping it all up in comedy makes it a much easier pill to swallow. And as much as I love Peter Krause, his stressful parenting makes for stressful watching. The kid has Asbergers, calm down already.
Plus, MODERN FAMILY manages to serves as many characters as PARENTHOOD, gives everyone an arc in an episode, and does it all in 30 pages? Come on, that is skill. Btw, none of this is to say that the real raw emotions in PARENTHOOD aren’t real or extremely well-written, I just prefer to take my family drama with a little sugar.
Weigh in folks. It’s not a blog if I don’t piss some people off.
Next week I’ll do a VAMPIRE DIARIES vs. TRUE BLOOD face-off.
Future Face-Off suggestions are welcome too. (and you don’t need to recommend the movie FACE/OFF, although it is a favorite Woo flick. Pigeons anyone?)